Earth Science CER Data Explorer

Analyze Real Data to Make Scientific Arguments

Use this page with your printed CER Data Analysis worksheet. Each tab below matches one Part of the worksheet. Read the data here; write your Claim, Evidence, and Reasoning on paper.

Part AEarthquake Depth and Magnitude

About this dataset

Twenty-three earthquakes recorded at tectonic plate boundaries, sorted into three depth groups. This is a teaching dataset: the values are representative of real subduction-zone patterns rather than a direct extract from one earthquake catalogue.

Question: Is there a relationship between earthquake depth and magnitude?
Scatter plot: earthquake magnitude against depth. Depth runs from 0 to 700 kilometres across the bottom; magnitude runs from 4 to 8 up the side. The earthquakes fall into three groups. Shallow quakes (less than 70 km) cluster at the far left and reach the highest magnitudes, spreading from 5.2 up to 7.1. Intermediate quakes (70 to 300 km) sit in the middle and stay lower, from 5.1 to 6.2. Deep quakes (more than 300 km) sit to the right and lowest of all, from 4.8 to 5.8. Reading left to right, the highest magnitude reached in each group gets smaller as depth increases, and the deepest quakes are squeezed into a narrow band near magnitude 5.

Selected earthquakes by location, depth, magnitude, and plate boundary type

Location Depth (km) Magnitude Plate Boundary Type
Japan Trench357.1Convergent
Chile Subduction1256.2Convergent
Mid-Atlantic Ridge105.8Divergent
San Andreas156.4Transform
Tonga Trench5805.2Convergent
Peru-Chile2005.9Convergent

Build Your CER Argument

Write your answers in the CLAIM, EVIDENCE, and REASONING boxes on Part A of your worksheet.

Claim

State your answer to the question in one clear sentence.

Evidence

Give at least 3 specific data points from the graph. Include the actual depth and magnitude values.

Reasoning

Explain the plate tectonic principles that account for this pattern.

Background

Earthquakes happen when rock breaks and slips along a fault. How strong the earthquake is depends on how much rock breaks at one time.

At a subduction zone, one plate slides down underneath another. The deeper that rock goes, the hotter it gets and the harder it is squeezed.

Cold rock near the surface is brittle. Brittle means it snaps, like a dry stick. Stress builds up for years, then a large block breaks all at once.

Hot rock deep down is ductile. Ductile means it bends and flows slowly, like warm taffy. Rock that bends does not store as much stress, so when it finally does break, a smaller block moves.

Think about it: if deep rock can only break in smaller pieces, what does that do to the largest magnitude you would expect to find down there?